Advisory Opinion

Page 4 of 5

Filter category

Feature post image

A Follow-Up on the ICJ’s UNRWA Advisory Opinion

In my previous post, I discussed the bottom line of the ICJ’s UNRWA advisory opinion – essentially the Court’s finding that Israel’s obligations under IHL, IHRL and the UN Charter compelled it not to obstruct UNRWA’s work, in the particular circumstances of the occupied territories. I did not discuss in that post the issue on which the judges seemed to have been the most divided, namely the interpretation of the duty to cooperate with the United Nations under Article 2(5) of the Charter, and I will not discuss it here either – Eliav Lieblich has an excellent post on Just Security that examines this question in detail. In this post, I will cover some issues that I personally found to be very interesting. But the AO raises many others; I am not aiming to be comprehensive (but I will be a bit nerdy). First, I will discuss the Court’s approach to the status of Gaza as an occupied territory. Second, its application of human rights law.

Read more

The Bottom Line of the ICJ’s UNRWA Advisory Opinion

Yesterday, the International Court of Justice delivered its advisory opinion on the Obligations of Israel in relation to the Presence and Activities of the United Nations, Other International Organizations and Third States in and in relation to the Occupied Palestinian Territory – which primarily deals with Israel’s ban on the operation of UNRWA, but also…

Read more

The Canary in the Coal Mine: Sawalkot Dam and the Indus Waters Treaty

Introduction Six months after New Delhi unilaterally put the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) ‘in abeyance’, India has fast-tracked the construction of the Sawalkot hydropower project on the Chenab river without conducting an effective Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). The Environment Ministry (India) granted final approval of the project, having been…

Read more

The ICJ’s Advisory Opinion on Climate Change: Does It Throw a Wrench into the Negotiator’s Toolbox of Diplomatic Problem-Solving Techniques?

The International Court of Justice’s recent Advisory Opinion on Climate Change (AO) has been widely celebrated by many States, non-governmental groups, and commentators as a victory for climate ambition and climate justice.  To the extent there have been criticisms, they have generally been on the basis that the…

Read more

Four Key Takeaways for Deep Sea Mining from the ICJ Advisory Opinion

Established by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the International Seabed Authority (ISA) is responsible for administering resources in the Area, including regulating Deep Sea Mining (DSM) activities (art. 156 UNCLOS). The role of the ISA and the DSM regime is amended and elaborated on in the 1994 Implementation Agreement…

Read more